dancing horses

dancing horses

Wednesday, July 5, 2023

Control Issues

 I know that an update is far overdue. The truth is that it's been raining non-stop for days and it's starting to get to me. 


I've been doing my best to squeeze in rides in between the rain but it's not easy. That is, of course, a first world problem. 

even the hens are seeking higher ground
I am, however, getting worried about getting hay. I am getting near the end of my stack and we'll need a number of dry days before hay can be cut. But I guess I'll file that under 'things I have zero control over'. 

I need to be more zen like Ripley

Not that you can tell, but I didn't actually write this post to bitch about the weather. I wanted to share some learning that is really starting to take root. It's interesting how, when you're learning something, that you see that lesson everywhere. In my case I've seen it a lot in my lesson, blog posts and from other online learning. 

Back in May at the Obstacle Clinic, Mike and Nikki reviewed (as they always do) the idea of teaching a horse to control his own feet. The idea being that once a horse knows the task (like the balance beam), you shouldn't have to micro-manage them but give them freedom to make a mistake. Then correct the mistake and repeat. In this example, when Quaid walked off the balance beam half-way over on Sunday (a point at which he had been over it multiple times) I would back him up and then ask again. The backing up was a little uncomfortable (not a lot) and the going over properly was easy. 

doing a good job, even if this angle makes him look like a donkey

Carmen has been a bit spicy since right before our show. Not out of control but definitely opinionated. My riding is at the point where I can prevent her from doing her 90-degree-spin-and-bolt manoeuvre. Which is great. Except that I found myself doing this often is whatever spot of the day was 'certain death' (it moves around). 

screen grab from a lesson when a dog sneezed

What I realised was that every time we hit that spot I had to micromanage her through it. 

Every. Time. 

Clearly this was not the lesson I wanted her to learn. That she could go by a spot (like a sneezing dog) only if I had maximum control over her. So I decided to change things up. The first part of the ride I would micro-manage. That way she knew what I wanted and that I could get her through. 

And I knew she knew. And that she knew that I knew she knew. Y'know? 

Then when we went by I would keep my cues the same but everything soft. When she spun and bolted I simply allowed her to canter and we would canter a 15/20 metre circle until that felt like work. I would then bring her down to trot and go by that spot again, without making my cues any harder. My thoughts were that she needed to make a decision about how she was going to travel by and that there were consequences to choices. 


In my next lesson after I had this realisation (fyi all photos of me riding Carmen are from that lesson) Jane was really helping me to get Carmen off the inside leg and for me to let go of the inside rein. 

"you won't know she understands bending to the leg if you always use your hands"

Which is pretty much the same principle. 

In my rides after that lesson I realised how much Carmen pushes against my inside leg. When she does respond it's because she chooses to. I noticed that going through a corner it would not matter how much leg I had, she would not bend until we were through. Instead she would be looking out. Going down the side of the ring with the trees I could feel her entire weight shifted to the inside. That is not good from a bio-mechanic perspective. It will not help her to carry herself. 


I don't know if you can tell but all of her weight
is subtly shifted to the inside

If my leg cue is always at a 8/10 level there's not much more to go up without significant tension on my part. So I dug out my spurs. My incredibly mild and soft spurs.  The ones with the little ball that rolls along their sides. 

The first ride I asked with my leg and, when nothing happened, turned my spur into her side. Carmen reached around and tried to bite my foot. Which tells you everything you need to know about her thoughts on who is in charge. I laughed but did not give up. I did my very best to be very clear and simple: if she bent with the leg no spur. If she ignored leg, spur. It took maybe 2 rides and then I was able to stop wearing them. 

bending. Look Ma, no spurs

It's a bit of difficult thing to learn: ride every stride but don't micro-manage. I can feel Carmen getting more confident in her choices. If you are up by my ring you may even hear me say 'it's your choice, make it a good one'.  It's not easy to 'let go' when you ride a horse that can turn 90 degrees and be at mach 10 in a millisecond. It definitely unseats me. I have been doing some rides in my Spanish saddle to help. But the other day she did a spin and bolt and as I got my seat back in the saddle I gave her a big kick and put her into a canter. I didn't even stop to be scared. 

the result is that she's like butter. 

I think letting her make these choices is giving her more confidence too. She doesn't have to rely on me to control her feet- she's doing that. I am merely giving good advice. 

Anyway, that's where we are right now. 
What are you working on? 

If it doesn't stop raining soon I'm going to need different tack. 




10 comments:

  1. As you know, I’m working on a similar issue, but on the trail. I was micro-managing Tweed, but that was just an illusion, and when he decided he was done, up he went. They can, and will, escape our “control.” Lucky for me, Tweed does not spin and bolt, …yet, but they all have their preferred evasions. I’m going through the Warwick Schiller courses, and he’s defining and refining the idea: make the wrong thing hard and the right thing easy. Very interesting, and not at all punitive. Sounds like what you did with Carmen. She chose to canter off, and you just continued on with her choice. Also your work with Quaid on the beam.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I do see similarities. And you’re right- I’m not punishing, just going with what she gives me. I can actually feel her making the decision that it’s not worth it.

      Delete
  2. It must be in the water, everyone is having similar issues!
    I saw something on Rudy Horsemanship's page that hit home with me:
    *This morning a student said, “But he’s hanging on my left rein!”
    I replied, “Do a quick give.”
    Rider gives and retakes, and the horse immediately softens.
    I asked, “Tell me again who was hanging on the left rein?” *
    Riding Ruby today (and looking at some photos Ted took I realise that I ride with more contact on the reins than I should (read micromanage) so I worked on that and had a happier horse.
    I hear you about the weather- we bounce between thunderstorms/tornado warnings and too dang hot to ride so I do my horse stuff first thing in the morning.
    I'm going to have to make one of those balance beams!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I saw that same post. It’s a good one. It’s hard to let go when you don’t feel safe. But it is necessary.

      Delete
  3. Wow good for you for riding through the spin & bolt, and responding with movement. Impressive. Carmen is such a smart girl and learns quickly. You are a great team!

    I almost always ride with spurs. Well, when my horse isn't lame. Koda doesn't listen well otherwise, although I rarely roll them. I need the extension of my leg for my rolly-polly boy at key moments. I know folks are horrified of the thought. Personally don't know anyone who uses spurs inappropriately, although no doubt there are plenty.

    As for your rain, totally jealous. I sure wish there was a magical weather exchange system. Our pastures and hay fields are dormant.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It has been a hard spring. May was a drought and then in June we had way more than normal rain. I wish I could send you rain. We need the wether to clear so that hay can be cut. It took a long time to learn how to ride out of the bolt with forward rather than stopping.

      Delete
  4. That rain! Interesting on the training concept. Similar to TRT for a spooky spot. The spooky spot is the point of ease and away from it is a little harder work. Over time the horse learns to make good choices.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm late commenting, but really wanted to thank you for posting this. You're often able to put the same feelings I have swirling around into a much more coherent thought process. I notice a huge difference between B, who I micromanaged (and to this day gradually falls apart if I don't), and Sophie, who I've consciously tried to be more. Of course she's the spooky one, so I really identify with the struggle of letting go.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for leaving a comment. I love the feedback.