But wait, there's even more lessons! If you've read my blog for any length of time you know that I have done many clinics with Johanna Beattie Batista over the years. She has been as much a part of my journey with Carmen as many other people. Johanna is a level 3 Centered Riding Instructor and has a long history of classical dressage training in Spain. She is now semi-retired and living in Portugal.
This year Stephanie and I managed to snag her to our area for 2 days of lessons. Johanna stayed with me and I transported her back and forth. It gave us time to have to some lovely chats.
A little side story: I told her about starting karate and she said 'good for you!'. It turns out that Centered Riding encourages their instructors to do martial arts training because it's so good for breath and body control. She herself does Tai Chi.
I did two lessons back to back on both horses. I do have some video and photos.
We started with Quaid. When I ride both horses I almost always start with Quaid because he's, well, easier. Carmen can be a bit draining so it's just better all around to start with him. If having these two has taught me anything (too much really), it's that it doesn't matter the age so much as the temperament.
![]() |
Cordelia fell in love with Johanna. It was hilarious and adorable. |
![]() |
lovely square halt |
This sort of work can be frustrating because it's so subtle and it's very tempting to just 'take' the contact. But, if I understood Johanna correctly, if he learns to go to the contact then everything will be easier as we move to more advanced work. Which I totally get. It was interesting because I suddenly felt when took the contact. It was cool.
![]() |
getting closer |
What I love about this horse is his try. He really wants to figure things out. He can get frustrated and annoyed but he almost never says 'no'.
Carmen went next and she was in a totally different mind set then Quaid. As you know I've been struggling with her barging through my rein aids and half-halts. It has been getting better but today she not in the mood for my crap. Johanna took one look at this said 'Okay, she's not allowed to pull this shit'. 'This shit' being leaning on my hands and pulling me all over the ring. There's a difference between being heavy and just bullying. As I think about it, it really is the same as her old behaviour of spook and bolt. But because she can't bolt on me anymore it manifests differently.
Anyway, Johanna's solution was to not let her build up a head of steam. I was to not ride any straight lines. I had to do 10 metre circles, shoulder in, haunches in, leg yields, half-pass, turn on the haunches, forehand., etc. This accomplished a few things: one she couldn't get super strong and pull the reins out of my hands, two, she had to think and three, it set her back on her hind legs and not her forehand. Carmen can be a real physical and mental ride and this was no exception. When we were done I felt pretty wrung out. I'm sure that Carmen felt the same. But we definitely ended in a good place.
After lunch Stephanie picked up Johanna because I had to wait for a repairman for my washing machine. Because, of course it would happen now. Adulting is hectic at times. Fortunately, it was an easy repair and I baked a cake while I waited. I managed to get to see Stephanie's ride. All I'll say is that its been wonderful to watch her partnership with her new horse blossom.
Bob and Stephanie came for dinner that night and Ed made a wonderful Mexican meal. After eating, laughing and talking they went home and we all collapsed into bed.
The next day was also cold but not super windy so that was a win. Quaid came out and was like 'oh I remember yesterday. You want this, right?' It was so neat to see the carryover. He felt a little tired to me as well. The day before hadn't seemed so hard but it's possible that he was just not feeling it. Either way we decided to work on him going forward into downward transitions and not just fall onto his forehand. It was a good lesson and, once again, it was wonderful to see how good he is given that he's five.
Then it was Carmen's turn. She was less feisty but still not super keen on the this whole work idea. We basically repeated the lesson from the day before- no straight lines. The goal was for her to come to contact without trying to take it over. Johanna kept repeating that the whole point of, say, a shoulder in was not that it be perfect. But that it keep her thinking and listening.
And it definitely worked, I could feel her come onto her hind leg and take real contact not 'gimme that rein' contact.
Here's a video.
At the end Johanna suggested that maybe a different bit would be better. I like her current bit in that it prevents her from getting her tongue over it. But I think I will try her in Quaid's bit to see if she's more respectful.
The next day I drove Johanna back to the city and gave her back to Stacie after a great lunch. It was a good two days and I really enjoyed the intensity of the work, even if I needed a nap after.
Going through exactly the same thing with Bella. Keep her mind busy. No long straight lines. Shoulder / haunches in. Damn mares! lol.
ReplyDeletelol. You mean I’m not alone?
DeleteNice work with both horses. You have your hands full schooling two. We are also working on soft transitions from walk, trot and lope. I didn’t notice you not breathing, but it makes sense. That was perceptive of Johanna. She seems like an excellent resource. I’d be training with her as much as possible. It seems like you went through quite a few bits with Carmen before. It would be nice if Quaid’s works out. It will make it easier.
ReplyDeleteCarmen is on her third bit. I’m not sure if I’ll switch. Before this recent issue she was going fairly well. But maybe not. She does have a large younger so perhaps Quaids thinner bit will suit her.
DeleteArwen went through a long time when we couldn't trot in a straight line without her tanking off. (This was last year, showing successfully at Third---there aren't too many straight lines there!) Not my favourite period in our journey together, but we got through it!
ReplyDeleteThank you! I needed to hear that. Part of me wonders if this a phase as we move her back on her hind. She has a big front end.
DeleteQ looks so nice! It's fun to feel when they "get it." Dalton takes a bit of warm up to then relax into contact. Carrying yourself is hard sometimes :D
ReplyDeleteIt really is hard!
DeleteHaving two such different horses is quite journey in horsemanship. I think you are up for the challenge though! You have some excellent mentors for your journey.
ReplyDeleteI’ve been very fortunate in my mentors.
DeleteI had a little understanding giggle when you mentioned riding Quaid first because he's easier. I've always done Al first because he's the hardest, but I've recently switched to doing him second for the same reason. I felt like I wasn't ever giving the other horses great rides because Al took it all out of me. So now I rotate one of the others before Al and everyone gets some good strong rides.
ReplyDeleteI like that approach with Carmen to keep her busy. And I love how smart Quaid is that he just picked right up on day 2 where he left off. What a good boy!
I’m glad you found the same as me. It’s just easier putting them second. I don’t know how you do 3!
DeleteSounds like you got the right lesson for each horse! I too have had to spend periods of time avoiding straight lines at all costs to keep both my horses from going in "auto-pilot", dropping on their forehand, and tuning me out. If I let Pyro do that then try to ask something of him, he gets fussy, hollows his back, and barrels through my leg. Missy shortens her neck and becomes braced, feeling like I'm trying to ride and bend a brick. Fun times~, but not permanent in my experience!
ReplyDeleteI had to shift my thinking and it was two great lessons for me.
DeleteQuaid is looking so grown up! Also feel ya on the whole “mare not in the mood” thing … sounds like a great set of lessons overall!
ReplyDeleteThank god our mares don’t blog. 😀
Delete